Your home’s siding faces Northeast Ohio’s brutal winters, humid summers, and lake-effect snow, all while shaping its curb appeal. For homeowners in Strongsville, North Royalton, Brunswick, and nearby cities, painting your siding, soffits, windows, and gutters is a budget-friendly way to refresh your exterior, while replacing siding often involves costly additional work like new gutters or wrapping soffit. At The Picky Painters, we specialize in premium exterior painting to revive any siding type. This guide covers seven siding materials, how painting can transform them, and a cost comparison to help you choose.
Table of Contents
- Vinyl Siding
- Wood Siding
- Fiber Cement Siding
- Brick Siding
- Metal Siding
- Stucco Siding
- Stone Veneer Siding
- Painting vs. Replacing Siding: Cost Comparison
1. Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding is a Strongsville favorite for its affordability and low maintenance. It resists moisture, rot, and pests, ideal for Northeast Ohio’s wet climate. Painting vinyl siding, soffits, and trim with premium Sherwin-Williams paint costs $1.50–$3.50 per square foot, compared to $4–$8 for replacement, plus extra for gutters or soffits. It lasts 20–40 years.
Exterior Tips for Vinyl Siding:
- Choose insulated vinyl for energy savings in Berea’s cold winters.
- Power wash annually before painting for a smooth finish.
- Use UV-resistant paints to prevent fading in Ohio’s sun.
Want to refresh your vinyl siding and soffits? Contact The Picky Painters at (216) 403-2545 for a free Strongsville quote!
2. Wood Siding
Wood siding adds timeless charm to Medina’s upscale homes. Cedar or redwood can be painted or stained, but it needs maintenance against Ohio’s humidity. Painting wood siding, windows, and trim costs $2.00–$3.50 per square foot, while replacement runs $8–$15+, plus soffit or gutter costs. Repaint every 5–10 years.
Exterior Tips for Wood Siding:
- Apply a water-repellent sealants before painting to protect against Brunswick’s moisture.
- Use high-quality primer for better paint adhesion.
- Inspect for termites or rot yearly in North Royalton’s wooded areas.
3. Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding mimics wood’s look with superior durability, perfect for Strongsville’s weather. It resists fire, rot, and termites and can be painted with soffits for $1.50–$3.50 per square foot, versus $6–$12 for replacement, excluding gutters. It lasts up to 50 years.
Exterior Tips for Fiber Cement Siding:
- Hire pros like The Picky Painters for flawless painting over fiber cement.
- Repaint every 10–15 years to maintain vibrancy in Cleveland’s climate.
- Check for cracks to prevent moisture during heavy rains.
4. Brick Siding
Brick siding offers elegance for Medina’s luxury homes. It’s fire-resistant and insulating, cutting energy bills in Northeast Ohio winters. Painting brick and windows costs $1.50–$3.00 per square foot, while replacement is $9–$20, plus soffit or gutter expenses.
Exterior Tips for Brick Siding:
- Inspect mortar joints yearly for wear in Strongsville’s freeze-thaw cycles.
- Use breathable paints to prevent moisture trapping.
- Clean with a mild detergent before painting for a lasting finish.
5. Metal Siding
Metal siding (aluminum or steel) brings a modern vibe to Brunswick’s homes. It’s fire- and insect-resistant but can dent. Painting it with soffits costs $1.50–$3.00 per square foot, compared to $4–$14 for replacement, plus gutter costs.
Exterior Tips for Metal Siding:
- Choose rust-resistant paints for North Royalton’s humid conditions.
- Wash every few years and to prep for painting.
- Repair dents where possiabl before painting for a sleek finish.
6. Stucco Siding
Stucco siding, less common in Northeast Ohio, offers texture for Medina’s drier microclimates. Painting stucco and trim costs $2.00–$3.50 per square foot, while replacement is $6–$15, excluding soffits or gutters. Its texture requires careful prep.
Exterior Tips for Stucco Siding:
- Clean with a pressure washer to remove Berea’s dust before painting.
- Seal cracks to prevent water damage in rainy seasons.
- Use elastomeric paints for flexibility on stucco.
7. Stone Veneer Siding
Stone veneer siding adds luxury to Strongsville’s high-end homes at $8–$18 per square foot for replacement. Painting it with soffits costs $1.50–$3.50 per square foot, offering an affordable refresh.
Exterior Tips for Stone Veneer Siding:
- Use sealants before painting to block water in Parma’s wet climate.
- Clean with a hose to remove debris.
- Inspect for loose stones for a lasting painted surface.
Painting vs. Replacing Siding: Cost Comparison for Northeast Ohio Homes
Deciding between painting or replacing your siding? Painting, offered by The Picky Painters, transforms your Strongsville, Brunswick, or Parma home in days, covering siding, soffits, windows, and gutters at a fraction of replacement costs. Replacement, however, often requires costly extras like new gutters or soffit repairs. Here’s how 2024–2025 Northeast Ohio costs compare:
By Siding Square Foot
| Service | Cost per Sq Ft | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Painting Siding | $1.50 – $3.50 | Includes prep, primer, 2 coats of premium paint, soffits, windows, gutters; higher for wood/stucco. |
| Replacing Siding | $4.00 – $15.00+ | Vinyl ($4–$8), fiber cement ($6–$12), wood/stone ($8–$15+). Excludes soffits, windows, gutters, adding $1,000–$10,000+. |
By House Size (Living Sq Ft)
| Home Size | Est. Siding Sq Ft | Painting Cost | Replacement Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 sq ft | 1,500–2,000 | $2,250 – $7,000 | $6,000 – $30,000+ |
| 2,000 sq ft | 3,000–4,000 | $4,500 – $14,000 | $12,000 – $60,000+ |
| 3,000 sq ft | 4,500–6,000 | $6,750 – $21,000 | $18,000 – $90,000+ |
Why Paint? Painting is 3–5x cheaper, includes soffits, windows, and gutters, and boosts curb appeal in days with premium paints for Northeast Ohio’s climate. It’s perfect if your siding is sound.
Why Replace? Replacement fixes damage and adds insulation but is costly, disruptive, and often requires extra work like new gutters ($5–$15 per linear foot) or soffit repairs ($500–$2,000).
Unsure what’s best? With 25+ years of experience Joe @ The Picky Painters can assess your siding and provide a free quote. Call (216) 403-2545 or visit ThePickyPainters.com today!
FAQ
Q1: How do I know if my siding just needs paint or a full replacement?
A: If siding shows only fading or minor cracks, paint may buy you years of curb appeal. But warping, rot, or widespread damage often signals replacement is more cost‑effective in the long run.
Q2: Which siding option works best in Strongsville’s mix of hot summers and snowy winters?
A: Fiber cement and insulated vinyl hold up well against both heat and moisture. Wood can look beautiful but requires more upkeep in Ohio’s climate swings.
Q3: Does replacing siding really add more value than fresh paint?
A: Yes. A full siding replacement is one of the top exterior remodels for return on investment, often boosting resale value and energy performance more than paint ever could.
